A deadly boat crash during a fishing competition on Smith Lake in Cullman County, Alabama, has left three people dead. The incident occurred Wednesday, April 16, 2025 near Burr’s Island, just outside the Miller Bottoms area, during the second day of a fishing event.
According to officials, the crash involved at least two vessels — a Nitro Bass Boat and a Center Console boat. The victims have been identified as Joey Broom; John Clark; and Jeffrey Little. Emergency responders arrived quickly, but Broom was pronounced dead at the scene.
Ongoing Investigation and Community Response
The Alabama Law Enforcement Agency (ALEA) is currently leading the investigation into the cause of the crash. Investigators are examining the circumstances surrounding the collision, including possible speed, navigational errors, visibility conditions, or mechanical failure.
Numerous agencies responded to the emergency, including the Cullman County Sheriff’s Office, local fire departments, emergency medical services, and ALEA’s Marine Patrol Division. Authorities have asked the public to avoid the crash site as recovery and investigative operations continue.
Major League Fishing (MLF), which was hosting the Tackle Warehouse Invitational at the time, confirmed that one of the tournament’s competitors, Flint Davis of Georgia, was among those injured in the crash. The full extent of other injuries has not yet been disclosed, though MLF canceled the remainder of the tournament in the wake of the tragedy.
The Risks of Boating During High-Activity Events
Incidents like this highlight the serious dangers involved in recreational and competitive boating, especially during high-traffic events such as fishing tournaments. When multiple vessels are operating in close proximity — often at speed and under time pressure — the chances of a collision or navigation error increase.
Contributing factors in serious boating crashes can include:
- Operator inattention or fatigue
- Excessive speed or reckless maneuvering
- Equipment failure or improper maintenance
- Inadequate signage or crowd control at event sites
- Lack of coordination between participants and officials
Accidents involving fishing tournaments are particularly sensitive due to the presence of spectators, competitors, and high-value gear on board. Investigations typically assess whether safety protocols were followed and whether proper oversight was maintained.
Legal Options After a Boating Accident
When someone is killed or injured in a boating accident, the legal responsibility may extend beyond just the individual operator of the vessel. Boat manufacturers, event organizers, or third-party sponsors may bear liability if negligence, equipment failure, or lack of safety measures contributed to the crash.
Surviving family members may be eligible to pursue a wrongful death claim for damages such as:
- Funeral and burial expenses
- Lost income and future support
- Emotional pain and suffering
- Loss of companionship
Similarly, injured survivors may have grounds to file personal injury claims to recover medical costs, lost wages, and other related damages.
Contact Spagnoletti Law Firm
If you or your loved ones have been affected by a boating accident — whether during a public event, a private excursion, or as bystanders — it’s essential to understand your rights. Determining liability in a complex crash like the one on Smith Lake requires a thorough legal and technical investigation.
Spagnoletti Law Firm has experience handling maritime and boating accident cases and can assist in evaluating your potential claim. We work to identify negligent parties and pursue compensation on behalf of families impacted by preventable waterway tragedies.
For a free consultation with a maritime attorney, call 713-804-9306 today. There are no fees unless we recover compensation for you.
Spagnoletti Law Firm – Supporting victims of serious boating incidents across the U.S.